When Ben put out the call for machinimists to participate in the Ed Wood Festival, he wanted to open it up to anyone. He sent notices to several of the bigger gaming news sites. I don’t know if he anticipated a negative reaction, but he certainly got one on Kotaku.
It started off with a writer calling SL residents incompetent:
Ed Wood and Second Life go together like chocolate and peanut butter. After all, Ed was a director of inspired incompetence; Second Life is an entire virtual world filled with that incompetence.
Then it progressed to comment flaming, with readers speculating that it must be a slow news week and that they might actually HAVE TO WORK. Ben had the perfect response, though:
;.; My news was better. And I have to take issue with the statement that SL is filled with incompetence – unlike most VWs, competence is not measured by how long you are logged in, killing rats, but rather, how good you are. I understand it is hard to get used to a world that is mostly built by the untrained, but having been a part of that community for over 4 years now, it is amazing how competent those same untrained users have become as time progresses.
That is kind of the crux of the problem – those who are infatuated with SL (like myself) see it for it’s potential, and are investing in that by contributing to the community early. Those who hate on SL, like all the previous commentors and many of Kotaku’s authors, see it how it is today, and are unwilling to invest in it when there seem to be so many more “complete” worlds, even if they are unlikely to grow to be more.
Oh well, it’s still a fun time, and it does draw on many of SL’s strengths – so I hope some folks may want to participate in this years festival.
You rock, Ben! Keep up the good work and thank you for caring about the community.